The
Blessing of Abortion and Worship of Me Me Me
WORLD ^ | 5/9/09 | Marvin Olasky
Saturday, April 25, 2009
The judgment
that is come upon the
Drawing
these lines people say in despair well who then can be righteous? And that is exactly the point that the whole
church, the whole of the people that call themselves by the name of the Lord
are utterly sinful and corrupt, and are brazenly disobedient and teach such
sinfulness, corruption, and disobedience and that is why God’s judgment is
come.
"Abortion is a blessing and
our work is not done. Let me hear you say it: abortion is a blessing and our
work is not done. Abortion is a blessing and our work is not done. Abortion is
a blessing and our work is not done."
That was the
Rev. Katherine Hancock Ragsdale in 2007, repetitiously inciting her disciples
to be not just pro-choice but fanatically pro-abortion. This is significant
because, according to standard journalistic stylebooks, Ragsdale does not
exist. We're told that pro-choice folks don't like abortion; they're just
trying to help a woman facing tragedy.
Ragsdale,
though, says abortion is a "blessing," and not only in harsh
situations but good ones: "When a woman becomes pregnant within a loving,
supportive, respectful relationship; has every option open to her; decides she
does not wish to bear a child; and has access to a safe, affordable
abortion—there is not a tragedy in sight—only blessing. The ability to enjoy God's good gift of
sexuality without compromising one's education, life's work, or ability to put
to use God's gifts and call is simply blessing."
Ragsdale is
in the news because of a plum appointment: On July 1 she is scheduled to become
president of Episcopal
Hear some
more of Ragsdale's statement to her troops: "I want to thank all of you
who protect this blessing—who do this work every day: the health care
providers, doctors, nurses, technicians, receptionists, who put your lives on
the line to care for others (you are heroes—in my eyes, you are saints); the
escorts and the activists; the lobbyists and the clinic defenders; all of you.
You're engaged in holy work."
Ragsdale is a member of the board of NARAL
Pro-Choice America and for eight years chaired the Religious Coalition for
Reproductive Rights. Nevertheless, calling abortion "holy work"
seemed so over-the-top that WORLD called Ragsdale to ask whether a fanatic had
taken her name in a variant of identity theft. Ragsdale acknowledged that the words
were hers and that she still identified abortion with "blessing." She
said, though, that she had pulled that speech off her website because it was
"creating an occasion for sin" as readers posted critical comments.
She also said she's "really busy and can't keep up with the comments
coming in."
How has Ragsdale developed her position? I looked
on her website at sermons that remain. In 2005 she asked -rhetorically why
pro-lifers did not look at pro-aborts "with tolerance and respect."
She then said, "The answer to that question is that in this arena it is
women who must make the final decision and that you do not respect the moral
agency (or full personhood) of women simply because we are women."
Convenient: It's not about life; it's about sexism.
But go back further, to an Easter sermon in 2003
when she said that the Resurrection may never have happened. (Paul wrote to the
Corinthians, "If Christ has not been raised, our faith is futile . . . we
are of all people most to be pitied.") And go back further to Easter 2002:
"The suffering and death of Jesus, according to the theory of the
Atonement, pays for our sins and buys our salvation. It's an interesting
theory, but not one that I find compelling."
Some denominations have cracked open on issues of
homosexual ordination, but the fissure began long before, when clerics put God
on trial and chose which doctrines they found compelling. In 2003, proclaiming
her lesbianism, Ragsdale took aim at those who say that "we can't help
being gay—the old take pity, have mercy, argument. You know,
the one that concludes with a plaintive—who would choose this? Let me
answer that with three words: Me! Me! Me!"
The tragedy of abortion is bad enough, but the
origin of the tragedy, and so many others of our time, emerges from worship not
of Christ but of "me, me, me." Katherine
Ragsdale may show this tendency in a heightened form, but all of us display it
to some degree. May God have mercy on her, on her students, and on all of us.