Quotes
from the Past
(The Cainridge Revival of 1799-1804)
Originally compiled by Bill Britton
**All blue text
is comments and added text
From the History of Tennessee
Published by Goodspeed publishing company,
1887
Entered according the act of Congress 1886
Office of the Library of Congress, at Washington DC
Chapter XVlll Religious History (excerpts
from pages 645-665
Quote: One of the first to arrive within
the limits of the state was the reverend Charles Cumming.
A Presbyterian minister who preached regularly to a congregation
on the Holson valley not far from Abingsom, Virginia, as early
as 1772. It was the custom of Mr. Cummings on Sunday morning
to dress himself neatly put on his shot pouch , shoulder rifle,
mount his horse and rife to church, where he would meet the
congregation, each man with his rifle in hand. Entering the
Church he would walk gravely through the crowd, ascend his
pulpit, and after depositing his in one corner of it , so
as to be ready for any emergency, commence the solemn services
of the day. (The preachers spoken of within these pages were circuit-riding
preachers and each had several parishes they preached in over
the course of a month.)
In 1799 a sacramental meeting was held in
the old Red River Baptist Church Near Port Royal, which considering
the sparsely settled condition of the country , was quite
largely attended, Elders James McGready, William
Hodge and John Rankin,
of the Presbyterian Church and Elder John McGee of the Methodist
Episcopal Church were present. After a remarkable public address
by Elder Hodge . . . Elder
McGee arose , expressed his conviction that a greater than
he was preaching (The Elder Hodge
was preaching prophetically) exorted the people to
let the Lord God Omnipotent reign in their hearts, and broke
into the following song:
“Come
Holy Spirit, Heavenly Dove
With all thy quickening Powers,
Kindle a flame of sacred love
in these cold hearts of ours.”
Having sung thus far two aged ladies Mrs.
Pacely and Mrs. Clark commenced tremendous vociferating sentiments
of praise (They started shouting praise as the presence of God fell on
them.) and thanksgiving to
the Most High for his grace in providing redemption for a
fallen world, for some time the preacher attempted to continue
his singing, but the venerable ladies vociferated louder than
before; others of congregation united their voices with their
in praise; the minister descending from the pulpit passed
along the aisles vehemently shouting and exhorting: the clamor
and confusion increased tenfold, screams of mercy (Repentance)
were mingled with shouts of joy; a universal (Felt by all) and powerful
agitation (Wave of conviction
of the Holy Ghost) pervaded
the multitude; suddenly individuals began to fall prostrate
to the floor as if dead , where they lay for some time unconscious or
unable to rise.
The Presbyterian
Elders were so surprised and even astonished at this confusion
(Despite the preaching of
Elder Hodge and the Exhortation and sing of Elder McGee) in the house of the
Lord,
that they made their way outside and quietly queried among
themselves “What is to be done?” Elder Hodges concluded that
nothing could be done if it were the work of satan it would
not last; and if it were the work of God efforts to control
it or check the confusion would be in vain. He thought it was of God, and decided to join
in ascribing glory to God’s name.
All three therefore
re-entered the house and found nearly the entire congregation
on the floor. Soon two or more at a time began to rise shouting
praise for the EVIDENCE FELT for sins forgiven, for redeeming
grace and undying love
Such was the beginnings
of the religious movement which on account of the strange
bodily agitations attending upon it, was looked upon as the
most wonderful event of the times.
The next meeting
was held on the following Saturday and Sunday at the beach
meeting house , ten miles west of Gallatin, Sumner county
where was present a vast assembly and where were witnessed
scenes similar to those above described.
(INSERTED
AS BACKGROUND) McGready had three small congregations in Muddy
River, Red River and Gasper River in Logan County in the southwest
of the state. The majority of the people were refugees from
all states in the Union who fled from justice or punishment.
They included murderers, horse thieves, highway robbers, and
counterfeiters. The area was nicknamed Rogues Harbour.
'The
first real manifestations of God's power came, however, in
June 1800. Four to five-hundred members of McGready's three
congregations, plus five ministers, had gathered at Red River
for a "camp meeting" lasting several days. On the
final day, "a mighty effusion of [God's] Spirit"
came upon the people, "and the floor was soon covered
with the slain; their screams for mercy pierced the heavens."
'Convinced
that God was moving, McGready and his colleagues planned another
camp meeting to be held in late July 1800 at Gasper River.
They had not anticipated what occurred. An enormous crowd
- as many as 8,000 - began arriving at the appointed date,
many from distances as great as 100 miles. ... Although the
term camp meeting was not used till 1802, this was
the first true camp meeting where a continuous outdoor service
was combined with camping out. ...
'At a huge evening meeting lighted by flaming torches ... a Presbyterian
pastor gave a throbbing message ... McGready recalled: The
power of God seemed to shake the whole assembly. Toward the
close of the sermon, the cries of the distressed arose almost
as loud as his voice. After the congregation was dismissed
the solemnity increased, till the greater part of the multitude
seemed engaged in the most solemn manner. No person seemed
to wish to go home - hunger and sleep seemed to affect nobody
- eternal things were the vast concern. Here awakening and
converting work was to be found in every part of the multitude;
and even some things strangely and wonderfully new to me'
(Church History magazine, No. 23, p 25).
1801
August - Cane Ridge, Kentucky (Barton Stone)
Impressed
by the revivals in 1800, Barton Stone, a Presbyterian minister,
organised similar meetings in 1801 in his area at Cane Ridge
north-east of Lexington. A huge crowd of around 12,500 attended
in over 125 wagons including people from Ohio and Tennessee.
At that time Lexington, the largest town in Kentucky, had
less than 1,800 citizens. Now Presbyterian, Methodist and
Baptist preachers and circuit riders formed preaching teams,
speaking simultaneously in different parts of the camp grounds,
all aiming for conversions of sinners.
James
Finley, later a Methodist circuit rider, described it:
'The
noise was like the roar of Niagara. The bast sea of human
being seemed to be agitated as if by a storm. I counted seven
ministers, all preaching at one time, some on stumps, others
in wagons and one standing on a tree which had, in falling,
lodged against another. ...
'I
stepped up on a log where I could have a better view of the
surging sea of humanity. The scene that then presented itself
to my mind was indescribable. At one time I saw at least five
hundred swept down in a moment as if a battery of a thousand
guns had been opened upon them, and then immediately followed
shrieks and shouts that rent the very heavens' (Pratney 1994:104).
The
Rev. Moses Hoge wrote: 'The careless fall down, cry out, tremble,
and not infrequently are affected with convulsive twitchings
...
'Nothing
that imagination can paint, can make a stronger impression
upon the mind, than one of those scenes. Sinners dropping
down on every hand, shrieking, groaning, crying for mercy,
convulsed; professors praying, agonizing, fainting, falling
down in distress, for sinners or in raptures of joy! ...
On
the Sunday following this meeting a most wonderful meeting
was held at Muddy River Church , a few miles north of Russellville,
Kentucky. (These Circuit riding
preachers had to travel hundreds of miles on horseback between
meetings they had to be able to feed and care for themselves
off the land and travel between points on mostly trails as
few highways and roads existed at the time. So the revival
we are reading of was completely independent in every local.)
To this meeting
people came in all kinds of vehicles, on horseback and on
foot from all distances up to 100 miles (So God sovereignly calls a meeting in 1799 there are no signs
posted of a revival meeting. There are no promoters trying
to fill the place. It was only the Holy Ghost drawing whom
he will. This bears no resemblance of the man made monstrosity
that is called evangelistic or revival meetings of this day.
When Jesus held meetings they were not announced the
spirit drew “Unsaved” and “Saved” alike people traveling hundreds
of miles and usually far more than the capacity of the place
Christ was. It appears to me that in the first few episodes
listed God was more preparing these preachers for what was
to come.) Long before the hour of preaching came there were present
three times as many as the house could seat, and still they
came singing and in companies of tens fifties and hundreds.
A temporary pulpit was erected in the words and seats for
the multitudes made by felling large trees, and laying them
on the ground. Preaching commenced , and soon the presence
of the all-pervading power (of
God) throughout the vast
assembly. As night came on it was apparent the crowd did not
intend to disperse. Some took wagons and hurried to bring
straw for the barns and treading yards. Some fell to sewing
wagon sheets together., and other s cutting forks and pots
on which to spread them.
Counterpanes coverlets and sheets were also fastened
together to make tents or camps. Others were dispatched to
town and the nearest houses to collect bacon meal flour with
cooking utensils to prepare food for the multitude.
In
a few hours it was a sight to see how much had been gathered
for the encampment. Fires were made, cooking begun and by
dark candles were lighted abd fixed to hundreds of trees;
and here was the first and perhaps most beautiful campground
the world had ever seen. (2 years pass and people are now annually going out to these
camp meetings.)
The Reverend
Barton W. Stone a Presbyterian clergyman, pastor of Cane Ridge and Concord
congregations in Bourban county Kentucky hearing of the religious
excitement (Again I note that the excitement came from those who the Holy
Ghost drew and not some false pompous fervor form a paid evangelist
to stir a crowd.) in the
southern part of his own state and if the camp meeting in
Logan county Kentucky started in the spring of 1801 to attend one
of the camp meetings in Logan. Afterward he wrote a book describing
what he had seen, and as no one was gotten a more minute description
of the bodily agitation, otherwise known as the jerks or “epidemic
epilepsy”, the following extracts
from his work are introduced.
“On arriving I
found the multitude assembled on the edge if a prairie where
they continue encamped many successive days and nights during
all which time worship was conducted in some parts of the
encampment. The scene to me was passing strange. I baffles
description . Many many many fell down as men slain in battle,
and continued for hours together in breathless and motionless
state, sometimes for a few moments reviving and exhibiting
symptoms of life by deep groans (Speaking in tongues of men and of angels) or piercing shrieks, or by a prayer for mercy most fervently
uttered. After lying thus for hours they obtained deliverance.
The gloomy cloud that have covered their faces seemed gradually
and visibly to disappear, and hope in smiles to brighten into
Joy. They would then arise shouting deliverance and addressing
the surrounding multitude in language truly eloquent and impressive,
with Astonishment I heard men and women and children declaring
the glorious works of God and the mysteries of the Gospel.
(He is astonished that by revelation these are speaking things
well beyond their learning and education.) Their appeals were solemn heart rending bold and free. Under
such addresses many others would fall down in the same state
from which he speakers had just been delivered.
Austin
Taft speaks of his experience after he fell down : It seemed to me I had already entered the dark abodes of eternal night,
and right here something seemed to whisper to me—that there
was mercy for me. I stopped and listened for a moment. What
a word—mercy for me. It was the best news I ever heard. From
that moment my faith laid hold upon the Savior’s promises
with an unguiding grasp, and I saw a light in the distance
far above my head, which grew brighter as it came near, and
when it reached me I fell to the floor as quick as the lightning
flash, and that moment was filled with the fullness of God.
Old things passed away and all things became new. My happiness
was complete.…And I remained motionless for 45 minutes without
power to move a muscle. My good Presbyterian father thought
I was dead and talked of sending for the doctor.
Two or three of my particular acquaintances from a distance were
struck down. I sat patiently by on of them (Who I knew to
be a careless sinner) for hours and observed them with critical
attention everything from beginning to end. I noticed the
momentary reviving as if from death , the humble confession,
the fervent prayer and the ultimate deliverance: them solemn
thanks and praise to God. the affectionate exhortation to
companions and to the people around to repent and come to
Jesus. I was astonished at the knowledge of the Gospel truth
displayed in these exhortations. (He
is again astonished that by revelation these person he knows
all too well is speaking things well beyond his learning and
education.) The effect (of his preaching) was that
several others sank down into the appearance of death. After
attending to many of these cases my conviction was complete
that this was a good work, nor has my mind wavered since on
the subject.
The bodily agitations
or exercises attending the excitement were curious, and called
by various names, as the falling exercise, the jerks, the
dancing exercise, the barking exercise, the laughing and singing
exercises and so on. The falling exercise was very common
among all classes; saints, and careless sinners, of every age and grade from
philosophers, the those who behaved themselves as clowns.
The person involved
in this exercise would generally with a piecing scream fall
like a log on the floor or earth and appear as dead. The jerks
can not be so easily described. .Sometime the person beset
with the jerks would be affected on one part of area of their
body and other times in their whole body.
When the head alone was affected it would jerk backward
and forwards or from side to side so quickly that the persons
facial features could not be distinguished. When the whole
person was affected I have seen a person stand in one place
and jerk backward and forward in quick succession the head
nearly touching the floor behind and before. (Wow)
All classes saints as well as sinners (This removes any argument of the jerks being indicative of
the presence of a demon)
the strong (Later they speak of those who try to resist) as well as the weak were all this affected. When asked they could not account for what
happened but some have told me that while they were jerking
they were in the happiest moments of their life. (They
did not fear, nor were in pain or torment.)
The dancing experience generally began
with the jerks and was peculiar to professors
of religion. The participant after jerking awhile
began to dance and the jerks would cease. Such dancing was
heavenly to the spectators (These felt
the anointing and power of God from those who danced like
David before the Lord.) The smile of heaven shown upon the subject, and their whole
beings appeared to be assimilated into angels.
The Barking exercise, as opposers contemptuously
called it was nothing
but the jerks. (Of this manifestation I can say the author though he was a witness does not know what
he is talking about as it had not affected him personally
– in the Hebrew in the OT one word to prophesy is NABU and
it means to bark like a dog, These gruntings groanings and
barkings are the gift of tongues and are contained in many
verses in the OT and NT but because this has been hid even
to those in Pentecost and the Charismatic movement they have
created out of whole cloth flse doctrines concerning this
gift and operation,) A person affected with the jerks especially
in the head would OFTEN make a grunt of a bark from the suddenness
of the jerk (this
assumption by the writer is also incorrect.) The name of Barking
seems to have had its origin from and old Presbyterian preacher
of east Tennessee. He had gone in the woods for devotion and
was seized by the jerks. Standing near a sapling he caught
hold of it to prevent his falling and as his head jerked back
he gave a grunt or a kind of noise similar to a bark his face
upward. Some wag discovered him as he jerked and continued
to bark and reported locally that they saw the preacher barking
up a tree (This is the origin of the phrase “one barking up the wrong tree.”)
The laughing exercise was frequent.,
confined to the religious (Those who were right with
God) It was a loud hearty laughter but excited laughter in not
that saw it. The person
involved appeared many times rapturously solemn (This choice of words seems
paradoxical rapture denotes one who is beside themselves and
Solemn denotes one who has throttled their emotions it would
seem one could not be both.) And his laughter excited solemnity in saints and sinners. It
was truly indescribable.
The running exercise was nothing more
than the persons feeling something of thse bodily agitations,
through fear , attempted to run away and thus escape from
them (This is no more possible than when Saul sent his men of valor to
arrest David when he Hid among the prophets and they were
completely overcome by the Holy Spirit – the doctrine of the
Holy Ghost is a gentleman is utterly false.) but it commonly happened that they ran not too far before they
fell or they became so agitated that they could not proceed
any further.
The singing exerise was more unaccountable
than anything else that I ever saw. The subject endowed came into a very happy state of mind and would
sing most melodiously, NOT FROM THE MOUTH OR NOSE but entirely
from the breast, the sound issued thense. Such noise silencing
everthing and attracting the attention of all. (Jeremiah 4:3 Heart shall
sound like pipes.)
Elder Stone has been described as a
man of respectable bearing, of spotless character, and childlike
simplicity Like Elder Hodges and Dr. J. P. Campbell Elder
stone believed the Jerks were the work of God. Concluding
that it to be something beyond anything we had ever known
in nature.
Another contemporary that witnessed
these events was the celebrated Peter Cartwright and he reported
thus:
Just in the midst of our controversies
on the subject of the powerful exercises among the people
under preaching, a new exercise broke out among us, called
the jerks, which was overwhelming in its effects upon the
people, No matter whether they were saints of sinners they
would be taken under a warm song or a sermon and seized with
a convulsive jerking all over, which they could not possibly
avoid; the more they resisted the more they jerked. If they
would not strive against it, and would pray in earnest
the jerking would usually abate. I have seen more than
500 persons jerking at one time in my large congregations.
Most usually persons taken with the jerks , to obtain relief
as they said would rise up and dance. Some would run but could
not get away, some would resist; on such the jerks were severe.
To see these proud young gentlemen and ladies dressed in silks
jewelry and prunella (Hair pieces and hat pieces
that contain feathers and flowers) from top to toe, take the jerks would
of excite my risibility’s . The first jerk or so you would
see their fine bonnets and combs fly, and so sudden would
be the jerking of their head that their loose hair would crack
almost as loud as a Wagoner’s whip.
Besides other amusing experiences with
jerks, Peter Cartwright relates an account of a very different
nature of a man who was jerked to death, which is probably
the only case on record, a company of drunken rowdies attended
a camp meeting on what was called the Ridge, The jerks were
very prevalent. The leader of the rowdies was a very large,
drinking man, who cursed the jerks and all religion. Shortly
afterward he himself took the jerks and started to run, but
jerked so powerfully that he could not get away. Halting among
some saplings he took a bottle of whiskey out of his pocket
and swore he would drink the – jerks to death, but he jerked
so violently he could not get the bottle to his mouth. At
length, on account of a sudden jerk, his bottle struck a sapling,
was broken and his whiskey spilled upon the ground. A great
crowd gathered around him, and when he lost his whiskey he
became very enraged and swore very profanely. At length he
fetched a very violent attack, snapped his neck, and soon
expired.
Peter
Cartwright looked upon the jerks as a judgment sent from God
to bring sinners to repentance, and to show to professors
of religion that God could work “with or without means, to
the glory of His grace and the salvation of the world”. Lorenzo
Dow has also left his account of the jerks; He says: “
I have seen all denominations of religion exercised with the
jerks, gentleman and ladies, black and white, young and old
without exception…I believe it does not affect those naturalists
who try to get it to philosophize upon, (those
that are curious and want to analyze it) and rarely those who are the most pious,
but the lukewarm, lazy professor (One
who says I love God but does not in deed)
and the wicked are subject to it.” His opinion was that the
jerking was “entirely involuntary and not to be accounted
for on any known principal”.
The numbers that
were affected at different sacramental camp-meetings
were various. At Cabin Creek, May 1801, so many fell that
on the third night, to prevent their being trampled upon,
they were collected together and laid out in order, in two
squares of the meeting-house, covering the floor like so many
corpses. At Paint Creek, 200 fell. At Pleasant Point, 300,
and at Cane Ridge, In August 1801, as many as 3000 are computed
to have fallen. (The point
is that all of these were life changing conversions and the
high numbers in each congregation also demonstrate that despite
the preaching of the day 80-90 percent of these congregations
were in fact tares.)
The
great revival lasted through the years 1800, 1801, 1802 and
1803, and resulted in the conversion of many thousands
of people, though no very accurate estimate of the number
was ever made. Perhaps it’s most prominent peculiarity
was that it was a spontaneous outburst of religious emotion
among the masses. (Rather than an evangelist ginning up an audience
into a level of emotion as is the fare these days) There was no great revival preacher like Wesley or Whitefield;
there were not protracted meeting, at which by a long-continued
and united effort, a revival was gradually brought about.
But the camp-meetings were the result of the revival which
in an unusual manner came upon both preacher and people.
Another
characteristic of the revival was this: doctrinal and dogmatically
discussions were dispensed with. Their value seems to have
been entirely overlooked.
The efforts for the ministers were chiefly, if not wholly devoted to
the multitudes the great religious truth of the impossibility
of escape from punishment for sin, except through repentance
and the acceptance of Christ as the Savior of the world; hence, the people labored under a powerful
conviction of the necessity of reformation in their daily
lives, which is always of infinitely greater importance than
the doctrine of the decrees…
When the great excitement had died away, however, the discussion of
doctrines was again renewed. (In other words the professional
levites came in in mass to assert control and reel the people
in under their control instead of the Holy Ghost’s.) These bodily agitations, which within the stat
of Tennessee were, strange as it may first appear, confined
almost exclusively to the Methodists and Presbyterians, although
they were experienced to some extent by the Baptists. But to the Presbyterians
belong the credit of first putting a check to the largely
diminishing this wild extravagance. A minister of this denomination
( the Rev. Mr. Lyle) at a great camp-meeting in Paris, Ky.,
in 1803, arose, and in the strongest language denounced what
he saw as extravagant and even monstrous, and immediately
afterward, a part of the people under his leadership, took
decided ground against the jerks. From that moment the wonderful
movement began to decline.
((Though the revival first
began with the Presbyterians it was according to the author
the Presbyterians that with a vengeance came in and killed
the revival declaring it not of God.
Yet in a move of complete hypocrisy they attempting
to gather in for themselves as many of the souls that were
converted. Rejecting
the move of the Spirit and the witnesses among themselves
who had been their from the start, they instead chose as scripture
saith: The dog hath return to its own vomit.”
And they returned to their damning doctrines and turned
from Christ rather being lead by the dead man John Calvin
whose voice for them yet speaketh from the grave.)
Although generally supposed then to
be so, the manifestations in this revival were not be any
means new or peculiar to those times. Such agitations were
common and remarkable violent in the days of the Whitefields
and the Wesleys. They beat a close resemblance to what was
known as the jumping exercise in Wales. Besides these instances
of these exercises there were in France 200 years ago.
More wonderful manifestations that
any recorded as having been witnessed
in Tennessee. A quaint old book written in 1741 by
Rex. Charles Chauncey, a notes divine, entitled, “A WONDERFUL
NARRATIVE AND FAITHFUL ACCOUNT OF THE FRENCH PROFPHETS, THEIR
ASITATIONS, ESCTACIES AND INSPIRATIONS”, states that “ an
account of them would be almost incredible if they had not
happened in view of France, and been known all over Europe.
From the month of June 1688, to February following, there
arose 500 of 600 Protestants of both sexes who gave themselves
out as prophets and inspired with the Holy Ghost. The sect
soon became numerous; there were many thousands of them. They
had strange fits and these fits came upon them fits came on
them with tremblings, and faintings, as in a swoon, which
made them stretch out their arms and legs and stagger several
times before they dropped down. (Fell to the ground)
They remained caught up in prophetic ecstasy)
they uttered all that came into their mouths. They
said they saw the heavens opened, the angels, paradise and
hell. When the prophets had for awhile been under agitation
of body they began to prophesy, the burden of their prophecies
being ‘Amend your lives, repent ye, for the end of all things
draweth nigh. ’Persons of good understanding knew not what
to think of it – to hear little boys and young girls ( of
the dregs of mankind who could not so much as read) quote
many texts of the Holy Scripture…One child was thirteen of
fourteen months old and kept then in a cradle and had not
itself spoken a word, nor could it go alone. When they came
in where it was, the child spoke distinctly in French, with
a voice small like a child but loud enough to be heard well
over the room. There were numerous children from three, four,
and five years old and so on up to fifteen and sixteen, who
being seized with agitations and ecstasies delivered long
exhortations under inspiration, “ect.
(These
were the French Huguenots tens of thousands were slaughtered
for their faith.)
And we have yet to go back
another 300 years to 1530 and the great Anabaptist revival
from with all of fundamentalist was born these people were
endowed with a great outpouring of the spirit and prophesied
and demonstrated all manner of gifts. The revival was so great
it began with the tens the hundreds the thousands the tens
of thousands and the hundreds of thousands and in its day
it wrought a great deliverance of God breaking the back of
the Roman Catholic and Protestant persecutions.
What became of these
tens of thousands of converts:
By "early Evangelicalism," I refer to a more heterogeneous
phenomenon: the spread of religious revivalism throughout
the country as itinerant preachers brought their version of
the gospel to people in less developed regions of the expanding
country. This geographical spread accompanied, and hastened,
a loosening of the traditional theologetical tenets and ecclesiastical
structures of the major Protestant denominations, particularly
Baptism, Methodism and Presbyterianism. The principal focus
here is on these three denominations because they were the
most successful in their efforts to win converts among the
general population; by the time of the Civil War, "the South was 90 percent
Protestant, and 90 percent of the Protestants were Baptists
or Methodists."” So the Baptists – Southern Baptists were twice visited with
Holy Ghost revival first in their founding in the Anabaptist
revival and then this revival that took place from 1799 –
to the Civil War so between 1865 and 1910 they forgot their
spiritual roots.
I have inserted here Testimony of Charles Finney’s conversion --Who was not part
of this revival but a figure that while being revered by fundamentalists
and especially Baptists – his very words and testimony as
to his having a second distinct experience in salvation that
he called the baptism of the Holy Ghost – is soundly rejected.
And why because of corrupt denominational doctrines and authority
that must be obey above God.
Charles
Finney became well known in revivals in the nineteenth century.
A keen sportsman and young lawyer, he had a mighty empowering
by God's Spirit on the night of his conversion on Wednesday
10 October 1821. That morning the Holy Spirit convicted him
on his way to work. So he spent the morning in the woods near
his small town of Adams in New York State, praying. There
he surrendered fully to God. He returned his law office that
afternoon, assisting his employer Squire Wright to set up
a new office. He wrote:
'By
evening we had the books and furniture adjusted, and I made
a good fire in an open fireplace, hoping to spend the evening
alone. Just at dark Squire W--, seeing that everything was
adjusted, told me good night and went to his home. I had accompanied
him to the door, and as I closed the door and turned around
my heart seemed to be liquid within me. All my feelings seemed
to rise and flow out and the thought of my heart was, "I
want to pour my whole soul out to God." The rising of
my soul was so great that I rushed into the room back of the
front office to pray.
'There
was no fire and no light in this back room; nevertheless it
appeared to me as if it were perfectly light. As I went in
and shut the door after me, it seemed to me as if I met the
Lord Jesus Christ face to face. It seemed to me that I saw
him as I would see any other man. He said nothing, but looked
at me in such a manner as to break me right down at his feet.
It seemed to me a reality that he stood before me, and I fell
down at his feet and poured out my soul to him. I wept aloud
like a child and made such confession as I could with my choked
words. It seemed to me that I bathed his feet with my tears,
and yet I had no distinct impression that I touched him.
'I
must have continued in this state for a good while, but my
mind was too much absorbed with the interview to remember
anything that I said. As soon as my mind became calm enough
I returned to the front office and found that the fire I had
made of large wood was nearly burned out. But as I turned
and was about to take a seat by the fire, I received a mighty
baptism of the Holy Spirit. Without any expectation of it,
without ever having the thought in my mind that there was
any such thing for me, without any memory of ever hearing
the thing mentioned by any person in the world, the Holy Spirit
descended upon me in a manner that seemed to go through me,
body and soul. I could feel the impression, like a wave of
electricity, going through and through me. Indeed it seemed
to come in waves of liquid love, for I could not express it
in any other way. It seemed like the very breath of God. I
can remember distinctly that it seemed to fan me, like immense
wings.
'No
words can express the wonderful love that was spread abroad
in my heart. I wept aloud with joy and love. I literally bellowed
out the unspeakable overflow of my heart. These waves came
over me, and over me, and over me, one after another, until
I remember crying out, "I shall die if these waves continue
to pass over me." I said, "Lord, I cannot bear any
more," yet I had no fear of death' (Wessel 1977:20-22).
The
result? That night a member of the church choir which Finney
led called in at his office, amazed to find the former skeptic
in a 'state of loud weeping' and unable to talk to him for
some time. That young friend left and soon returned with an
elder from the church who was usually serious and rarely laughed.
'When he came in,' Finney observed, 'I was very much in the
state in which I was when the young man went out to call him.
He asked me how I felt and I began to tell him. Instead of
saying anything he fell into a most spasmodic laughter. It
seemed as if it was impossible for him to keep from laughing
from the very bottom of his heart' (Wessel 1977:22).
Next
morning, with 'the renewal of these mighty waves of love and
salvation' flowing through him, Finney witnessed to his employer
who was strongly convicted and later made his peace with God.
That morning, Finney continues, 'Deacon B-- came into the
office and said to me, "Mr. Finney, do you remember that
my cause is to be tried at ten o'clock this morning? I suppose
you are ready?" I had been retained to attend this suit
as his attorney.
'I
replied to him, "Deacon B--, I have a retainer from the
Lord Jesus Christ to plead his cause and I cannot plead yours."
'He
looked at me with astonishment and said, "What do you
mean?"
'I
told him, in a few words, that I had enlisted in the cause
of Christ, and then repeated that I had a retainer from the
Lord Jesus Christ to plead his cause, and that he must go
and get somebody else to attend his lawsuit. I could not do
it.
'He
dropped his head and without making any reply went out. A
few moments later, in passing the window, I observed that
Deacon B-- was standing in the road, seemingly lost in deep
meditation. He went away, as I afterward learned, and immediately
settled his suit privately. He then betook himself to prayer
and soon got into a much higher religious state than he had
ever been before.
'I
soon sallied forth from the office to converse with those
whom I might meet about their souls. I had the impression,
which has never left my mind, that God wanted me to preach
the Gospel, and that I must begin immediately. ...
'I
spoke with many persons that day, and I believe the Spirit
of God made lasting impressions upon every one of them. I
cannot remember one whom I spoke with, who was not soon after
converted. ...
'In
the course of the day a good deal of excitement was created
in the village because of what the Lord had done for my soul.
Some thought one thing and some another. At evening, without
any appointment having been made, I observed that the people
were going to the place where they usually held their conference
and prayer meetings. ...
'I
went there myself. The minister was there, and nearly all
the principal people in the village. No one seemed ready to
open the meeting, but the house was packed to its utmost capacity.
I did not wait for anybody, but rose and began by saying that
I then knew that religion was from God. I went on and told
such parts of my experience as it seemed important for me
to tell. ...
'We
had a wonderful meeting that evening, and from that day we
had a meeting every evening for a long time. The work spread
on every side.
'As
I had been a leader among the young people I immediately appointed
a meeting for them, which they all attended. ... They were
converted one after another with great rapidity, and the work
continued among them until only one of their number was left
unconverted.
The
following is the source material from Reverend Barton W. Stone’s
biography the last chapter is eye opening as the Presbyterians
close ranks and disfellowship those who were in the revival
from the first.
His mind is greatly agitated by Calvinistic speculations--He
re-examined the Scriptures, and cordially abandons Calvinism--Hears
of a great religious excitement in Logan county, Ky., in the
spring of 1801, and hastens to attend a Camp-meeting in that
county--Is astonished at the wonderful religious exercises--Multitudes
confess the Saviour--Returns from Logan filled with religious
zeal--Under his labors similar scenes occur at Caneridge and
Concord--Great excitement and religious interest pervade the
community--Married to Elizabeth Campbell, July, 1801--Great
Caneridge meeting
About this time my mind was continually tossed on the waves of speculative
divinity, the all-engrossing theme of the religious community
at that period. Clashing, controversial opinions were urged
by the different sects with much zeal and bad feeling. No
surer sign of the low state of true religion. I at that
time believed, and taught, that mankind were so totally depraved
that they could do nothing acceptable to God, till his spirit,
by some physical, almighty, and mysterious power had quickened,
enlightened, and regenerated the heart, and thus prepared
the sinner to believe in Jesus for salvation. I began
plainly to see, that if God did not perform this regenerating
work in all, it must be because he chose to do it for some,
and not for others, and that this depended on His own sovereign
will and pleasure. It then required no depth of intellect
to see that this doctrine is inseparably linked with unconditional
election and reprobation, as taught in the Westminster Confession
of Faith. They are virtually one; and this was the reason
why I admitted the decrees of /61/ election and reprobation,
having admitted the doctrine of total depravity. They are
inseparable.
Scores
of objections would continually roll across my mind against
this system. These I imputed to the blasphemous suggestions
of Satan, and labored to repel them as Satanic temptations,
and not honestly to meet them with scriptural arguments.
Often when I was addressing the listening multitudes on the
doctrine of total depravity, their inability to believe--and
of the necessity of the physical power of God to produce faith;
and then persuading the helpless to repent and believe the
gospel, my zeal in a moment would be chilled at the contradiction.
How can they believe? How can they repent? How can they do
impossibilities? How can they be guilty in not doing them?
Such thoughts would almost stifle utterance, and were as mountains
pressing me down to the shades of death. I tried to rest in
the common salvo of that day, i.e. the distinction between
natural and moral ability and inability. The pulpits were
continually ringing with this doctrine; but to my mind it
ceased to be a relief; for by whatever name it be called,
that inability was in the sinner, and therefore he could not
believe, nor repent, but must be damned. Wearied with the
works and doctrines of men, and distrustful of their influence,
I made the Bible my constant companion. I honestly, earnestly,
and prayerfully sought for the truth, determined to buy it
at the sacrifice of everything else.
On
a certain evening, when engaged in secret prayer and reading
my Bible, my mind became unusually filled with comfort and
peace. I never recollect of having before experienced such
an ardent love and tenderness for all mankind, and such a
longing desire for their salvation. My mind was chained to
this subject, and for some days and nights I was almost continually
praying for the ruined world. During this time I expressed
my feelings to a pious person, and rashly remarked, so great
is my love for sinners, that had I power I would save them
all. The person appeared to be horror-stricken, /62/ and remarked,
Do you love them more than God does? Why then does he not
save them? Surely, he has almighty power. I blushed, was confounded
and silent, and quickly retired to the silent woods for meditation
and prayer. I asked myself, Does God love the world--the whole
world? And has he not almighty power to save? If so, all must
be saved, for who can resist his power? Had I a friend or
child, whom I greatly loved, and saw him at the point of drowning,
and utterly unable to help himself, and if I were perfectly
able to save him, would I not do it? Would I not contradict
my love to him--my very nature, if I did not save him? Should
I not do wrong in withholding my power? And will not God save
all whom he loves?
These
were to me puzzling questions--I could not satisfactorily
solve them consistently with my faith. I was firmly convinced
that according to Scripture all were not saved--the conclusion
then was irresistible, that God did not love all, and therefore
it followed of course, that the spirit in me, which loved
all the world so vehemently, could not be the Spirit of God,
but the spirit of delusion. My mind became involved in gloom,
my troubles rolled back upon me with renewed weight, and all
my joys were gone. I prostrated myself before God in prayer;
but it was immediately suggested, you are praying in unbelief,
and "whatsoever is not of faith is sin." You must
believe or expect no good from the hand of God. But I cannot
believe; as soon could I make a world. Then you must be damned,
for, "he that believeth not shall be damned."--But
will the Lord condemn me to eternal punishment for not doing
an impossibility? So I thought. I shudder while I write it--blasphemy
rose in my heart against such a God, and my tongue was tempted
to utter it. Sweat profusely burst from the pores of my body,
and the fires of hell gat hold on me. In this uncommon state
I remained for two or three days.
From
this state of perplexity I was relieved by the /63/ precious
word of God. From reading and meditating upon it, I became
convinced that God did love the whole world, and that the
reason why he did not save all, was because of their unbelief;
and that the reason why they believed not, was not because
God did not exert his physical, almighty power in them to
make them believe, but because they neglected and received
not his testimony, given in the Word concerning his Son. "These
are written, that ye might believe that Jesus is the Christ,
the Son of God, and that believing, ye might have life through
his name." I saw that the requirement to believe in
the Son of God, was reasonable; because the testimony given
was sufficient to produce faith in the sinner; and the invitations
and encouragement of the gospel were sufficient, if believed,
to lead him to the Saviour, for the promised Spirit, salvation
and eternal life.
This
glimpse of faith--of truth, was the first divine ray of light,
that ever led my distressed, perplexed mind from the labyrinth
of Calvinism and error, in which I had so long been bewildered.
It was that which led me into rich pastures of gospel-liberty.
I now saw plainly that it was not against the God and Father
of our Lord Jesus Christ that I had been tempted to blaspheme,
but against the character of a God not revealed in the Scriptures--a
character no rational creature can love or honor--a character
universally detested when seen even in man; for what man,
professing great love for his children, would give them impossible
commands, and then severely punish them for not doing them;
and all this for his mere good pleasure? What man acting thus
would not be despised as a monster, or demon in human shape,
and be hissed from all respectable society? Shall we dare
to impute such a character to the God of the universe?
Let
me here speak when I shall be lying under the clods of the
grave. Calvinism is among the heaviest clogs on Christianity
in the world. It is a dark mountain between heaven and earth,
and is amongst the /64/ most discouraging hindrances to sinners
from seeking the kingdom of God, and engenders bondage and
gloominess to the saints. Its influence is felt throughout
the Christian world, even where it is least suspected. Its
first link is total depravity. Yet are there thousands of
precious saints in this system.
As
might be expected, many objections arose in my mind against
the doctrines just received by me, and these objections were
multiplied by a correspondent, a Presbyterian preacher, to
whom I had communicated my views. I resolved not to declare
them publicly till I could be able to defend them against
successful opposition. In a subsequent part of these memoirs,
the declaration and defence will be seen.
Things
moved on quietly in my congregations, and in the country generally.
Apathy in religious societies appeared everywhere to an alarming
degree. Not only the power of religion had disappeared, but
also the very form of it was waning fast away, and continued
so till the beginning of the present century. Having heard
of a remarkable religious excitement in the south of Kentucky,
and in Tennessee, under the labors of James McGready and other
Presbyterian ministers, I was very anxious to be among them;
and, early in the spring of 1801, went there to attend a camp-meeting.
There, on the edge of a prairie in Logan county, Kentucky,
the multitudes came together, and continued a number of days
and nights encamped on the ground; during which time worship
was carried on in some part of the encampment. The scene to
me was new, and passing strange. It baffled description. Many,
very many fell down, as men slain in battle, and continued
for hours together in an apparently breathless and motionless
state--sometimes for a few moments reviving, and exhibiting
symptoms of life by a deep groan, or piercing shriek, or by
a prayer for mercy most fervently uttered. After lying thus
for hours, they obtained deliverance. The gloomy cloud, which
had covered their faces, seemed gradually and visibly to disappear,
and hope /65/ in smiles brightened into joy--they would rise
shouting deliverance, and then would address the surrounding
multitude in language truly eloquent and impressive. With
astonishment did I hear men, women and children declaring
the wonderful works of God, and the glorious mysteries of
the gospel. Their appeals were solemn, heart-penetrating,
bold and free. Under such addresses many others would fall
down into the same state from which the speakers had just
been delivered.
Two
or three of my particular acquaintances from a distance were
struck down. I sat patiently by one of them, whom I knew to
be a careless sinner, for hours, and observed with critical
attention every thing that passed from the beginning to the
end. I noticed the momentary revivings as from death--the
humble confession of sins--the fervent prayer, and the ultimate
deliverance--then the solemn thanks and praise to God--the
affectionate exhortation to companions and to the people around,
to repent and come to Jesus. I was astonished at the knowledge
of gospel truth displayed in the address. The effect was,
that several sunk down into the same appearance of death.
After attending to many such cases, my conviction was complete
that it was a good work--the work of God; nor has my mind
wavered since on the subject. Much did I then see, and much
have I since seen, that I considered to be fanaticism; but
this should not condemn the work. The Devil has always tried
to ape the works of God, to bring them into disrepute. But
that cannot be a Satanic work, which brings men to humble
confession and forsaking of sin--to solemn prayer--fervent
praise and thanksgiving, and to sincere and affectionate exhortations
to sinners to repent and go to Jesus the Saviour.
I
am always hurt to hear people speak lightly of this work.
I always think they speak of what they know nothing about.
Should every thing bearing the impress of imperfection be
blasphemously rejected, who amongst us at this time could
stand? But more on this subject hereafter. /66/
The
meeting being closed, I returned with ardent spirits to my
congregations. I reached my appointment at Caneridge on Lord's-day.
Multitudes had collected, anxious to hear the religious news
of the meeting I had attended in Logan. I ascended the pulpit,
and gave a relation of what I had seen and heard; then opened
my Bible and preached from these words: "Go ye into all
the world and preach the gospel to every creature. He that
believeth and is baptized shall be saved, and he that believeth
not shall be damned." On the universality of the gospel,
and faith as the condition of salvation, I principally dwelt,
and urged the sinner to believe now, and be saved. I labored
to remove their pleas and objections, nor was it labor in
vain. The congregation was affected with awful solemnity,
and many returned home weeping. Having left appointments to
preach in the congregation within a few days, I hurried over
to Concord to preach at night.
At
our night meeting at Concord, two little girls were struck
down under the preaching of the word, and in every respect
were exercised as those were in the south of Kentucky, as
already described. Their addresses made deep impressions on
the congregation. On the next day I returned to Caneridge,
and attended my appointment at William Maxwell's. I soon heard
of the good effects of the meeting on the Sunday before. Many
were solemnly engaged in seeking salvation, and some had found
the Lord, and were rejoicing in him. Among these last was
my particular friend Nathaniel Rogers, a man of first respectability
and influence in the neighborhood. Just as I arrived at the
gate, my friend Rogers and his lady came up; as soon as he
saw me, he shouted aloud the praises of God. We hurried into
each others' embrace, he still praising the Lord aloud. The
crowd left the house, and hurried to this novel scene. In
less than twenty minutes, scores had fallen to the ground--paleness,
trembling, and anxiety appeared in all--some attempted to
fly from the scene panic stricken, but they either fell, or
/67/ returned immediately to the crowd, as unable to get away.
In the midst of this exercise, an intelligent deist in the
neighborhood, stepped up to me, and said, Mr. Stone, I always
thought before that you were an honest man; but now I am convinced
you are deceiving the people. I viewed him with pity, and
mildly spoke a few words to him--immediately he fell as a
dead man, and rose no more till he confessed the Saviour.
The meeting continued on that spot in the open air, till late
at night, and many found peace in the Lord.
The
effects of this meeting through the country were like fire
in dry stubble driven by a strong wind. All felt its influence
more or less. Soon after, we had a protracted meeting at Concord.
The whole country appeared to be in motion to the place, and
multitudes of all denominations attended. All seemed heartily
to unite in the work, and in Christian love. Party spirit,
abashed, shrunk away. To give a true description of this meeting
cannot be done; it would border on the marvellous. It continued
five days and nights without ceasing. Many, very many will
through eternity remember it with thanksgiving and praise.
On
the 2d of July, 1801, I was married to Elizabeth Campbell,
daughter of Col. William Campbell and Tabitha his wife, daughter
of Gen. William russell, of Virginia. My companion was pious,
and much engaged in religion. We hurried up from Muhlenberg,
where her mother lived, to be in readiness for a great meeting,
to commence at Caneridge shortly after. This memorable meeting
came on Thursday or Friday before the third Lord's-day in
August, 1801. The roads were literally crowded with wagons,
carriages, horsemen, and footmen, moving to the solemn camp.
The sight was affecting. It was judged, by military men on
the ground, that there were between twenty and thirty thousand
collected. Four or five preachers were frequently speaking
at the same time, in different parts of the encampment, without
confusion. The Methodist and Baptist preachers aided in the
work, and all appeared cordially united in it--of one mind
and one soul, and the salvation of sinners seemed to be the
great object of all. We all engaged in singing the same songs
of praise--all united in prayer--all preached the same things--free
salvation urged upon all by faith and repentance. A particular
description of this meeting would fill a large volume, and
then the half would not be told. The numbers converted will
be known only in eternity. Many things transpired there, which
were so much like miracles, that if they were not, they had
the same effects as miracles on the unfaithful and unbelievers;
for many of them by these were convinced that Jesus was the
Christ, and bowed in submission to him. This meeting continued
six or seven days and nights, and would have continued longer,
but provisions for such a multitude failed in the neighborhood.
To
this meeting many had come from Ohio and other distant parts,
who returned home and diffused the same spirit in their neighborhoods,
and the same works followed. So low had religion sunk, and
such carelessness universally had prevailed, that I have thought
that nothing common could have arrested the attention of the
world; therefore these uncommon agitations were sent for this
purpose. However, this was their effect upon the community.
As I have seen no history of these bodily agitations of that
day, but from the pens of enemies, or scorners; and as I have
been an eye and ear witness of them from the beginning, and
am now over three score and ten years of age, on the brink
of eternity, into which almost all of the old witnesses have
entered, therefore I will endeavor to give a description of
them in a distant chapter, for your information.
An
account of the remarkable religious exercises witnessed in
the beginning of the 19th century.
The
bodily agitations or exercises, attending the excitement in
the beginning of this century, were various, and called by
various names;--as, the falling exercise--the jerks--the dancing
exercise--the barking exercise--the laughing and singing exercise,
&c.--The falling exercise was very common among all classes,
the saints and sinners of every age and of every grace, from
the philosopher to the clown. The subject of this exercise
would, generally, with a piercing scream, fall like a log
on the floor, earth, or mud, and appear as dead. Of thousands
of similar cases, I will mention one. At a meeting, two gay
young ladies, sisters, were standing together attending to
the exercises and preaching at the time. Instantly they both
fell, with a shriek of distress, and lay for more than an
hour apparently in a lifeless state. Their mother, a pious
Baptist, was in great distress, fearing they would not revive.
At length they began to exhibit symptoms of life, by crying
fervently for mercy, and then relapsed into the same death-like
state, with an awful gloom on their countenances. After awhile,
the gloom on the face of one was succeeded by a heavenly smile,
and she cried out, precious Jesus, and rose up and spoke of
the love of God--the preciousness of Jesus, and of the glory
of the gospel, to the surrounding crowd, in language almost
superhuman, and pathetically exhorted all to repentance. In
a little while after, the other sister was similarly exercised.
From that time they became remarkably pious members of the
church.
I
have seen very many pious persons fall in the same way, from
a sense of the danger of their unconverted children, brothers,
or sisters--from a sense of the danger of their neighbors,
and of the sinful world. I have /70/ heard them agonizing
in tears and strong crying for mercy to be shown to sinners,
and speaking like angels to all around.
The
jerks cannot be so easily described. Sometimes the subject
of the jerks would be affected in some one member of the body,
and sometimes in the whole system. When the head alone was
affected, it would be jerked backward and forward, or from
side to side, so quickly that the features of the face could
not be distinguished. When the whole system was affected,
I have seen the person stand in one place, and jerk backward
and forward in quick succession, their head nearly touching
the floor behind and before. All classes, saints and sinners,
the strong as well as the weak, were thus affected. I have
inquired of those thus affected. They could not account for
it; but some have told me that those were among the happiest
seasons of their lives. I have seen some wicked persons thus
affected, and all the time cursing the jerks, while they were
thrown to the earth with violence. Though so awful to behold,
I do not remember than any one of the thousands I have seen
ever sustained an injury in body. This was as strange as the
exercise itself.
The
dancing exercise. This generally began with the jerks, and
was peculiar to professors of religion. The subject, after
jerking awhile, began to dance, and then the jerks would cease.
such dancing was indeed heavenly to the spectators; there
was nothing in it like levity, nor calculated to excite levity
in the beholders. The smile of heaven shone on the countenance
of the subject, and assimilated to angels appeared the whole
person. Sometimes the motion was quick and sometimes slow.
Thus they continued to move forward and backward in the same
track or alley till nature seemed exhausted, and they would
fall prostrate on the floor or earth, unless caught by those
standing by. While thus exercised, I have heard their solemn
praises and prayers ascending to God.
The
barking exercise, (as opposers contemptuously /71/ called
it,) was nothing but the jerks. A person affected with the
jerks, especially in his head, would often make a grunt, or
bark, if you please, from the suddenness of the jerk. This
name of barking seems to have had its origin from an old Presbyterian
preacher of East Tennessee. He had gone into the woods for
private devotion, and was seized with the jerks. Standing
near a sapling, he caught hold of it, to prevent his falling,
and as his head jerked back, he uttered a grunt or kind of
noise similar to a bark, his face being turned upwards. Some
wag discovered him in this position, and reported that he
found him barking up a tree.
The
laughing exercise was frequent, confined solely with the religious.
It was a loud, hearty laughter, but one sui generis;
it excited laughter in none else. The subject appeared rapturously
solemn, and his laughter excited solemnity in saints and sinners.
It is truly indescribable.
The
running exercise was nothing more than, that persons feeling
something of these bodily agitations, through fear, attempted
to run away, and thus escape from them; but it commonly happened
that they ran not far, before they fell, or became so greatly
agitated that they could proceed no farther. I knew a young
physician of a celebrated family, who came some distance to
a big meeting to see the strange things he had heard of. He
and a young lady had sportively agreed to watch over, and
take care of each other, if either should fall. At length
the physician felt something very uncommon, and started from
the congregation to run into the woods; he was discovered
running as for life, but did not proceed far till he fell
down, and there lay till he submitted to the Lord, and afterwards
became a zealous member of the church. Such cases were common.
I
shall close this chapter with the singing exercise. This is
more unaccountable than any thing else I ever saw. The subject
in a very happy state of mind would sing most melodiously,
not from the mouth or nose, but /72/ entirely in the breast,
the sounds issuing thence. Such music silenced every thing,
and attracted the attention of all. It was most heavenly.
None could ever be tired of hearing it. Doctor J. P. Campbell
and myself were together at a meeting, and were attending
to a pious lady thus exercised, and concluded it to be something
surpassing any thing we had known in nature.
Thus
have I given a brief account of the wonderful things that
happened in the great excitement in the beginning of this
century. That there were many eccentricities, and much fanaticism
in this excitement, was acknowledged by its warmest advocates;
indeed it would have been a wonder, if such things had not
appeared, in the circumstances of that time. Yet the good
effects were seen and acknowledged in every neighborhood,
and among the different sects it silenced contention, and
promoted unity for awhile; and those blessed effects would
have continued, had not men put forth their unhallowed hands
to hold up their tottering ark, mistaking it for the ark of
God. In the next chapter this will appear.
Hemorrhage of the lungs from excessive speaking, &c.--Attends
a camp meeting at Paris--Meets with opposition--Frees his
slaves--Richard M'Nemar, John Dunlavy, John Thompson, Robert
Marshall and himself concur in religious views--Revival checked
by opposition--Partyism rekindled--M'Nemar tried--Protest
against proceedings of Synod in M'Nemar's case, and withdrawal
of Richard M'Nemar, John Dunlavy, John Thompson, Robert Marshall
and himself from jurisdiction of Synod--They are suspended--Formed
themselves into a separate Presbytery, called Springfield
Presbytery--Apology published--Abandons Presbyterianism--Surrenders
all claim to salary--Last will and testament of Springfield
Presbytery.
Since
the beginning of the excitement I had been employed day and
night in preaching, singing, visiting and praying with the
distressed, till my lungs failed, and became inflamed, attended
with a violent cough and /73/ spitting of blood. It was believed
to be a dangerous case, and might terminate in consumption.
My strength failed, and I felt myself fast descending to the
tomb. Viewing this event near, and that I should soon cease
from my labors, I had a great desire to attend a camp-meeting
at Paris, a few miles distant from Caneridge. My physician
had strictly forbidden me to preach any more till my disease
should be removed.
At
this camp-meeting the multitudes assembled in a shady grove
near Paris, with their wagons and provisions. Here for
the first time a Presbyterian preacher arose and opposed the
work, and the doctrine by which the work amongst us had its
existence and life. He labored hard to Calvinize the people,
and to regulate them according to his standard of propriety.
He wished them to decamp at night, and to repair to the town,
nearly a mile off, for worship in a house that could not contain
half the people. This could not be done without leaving
their tents and all exposed. The consequence was, the meeting
was divided, and the work greatly impeded. Infidels and formalists
triumphed at this supposed victory, and extolled the preacher
to the skies; but the hearts of the revivalists were filled
with sorrow. Being in a feeble state, I went to the meeting
in town. A preacher was put forward, who had always been hostile
to the work, and seldom mingled with us. He lengthily addressed
the people in iceberg style--its influence was deathly. I
felt a strong desire to pray as soon as he should close, and
had so determined in my own mind. He at length closed, and
I arose and said, let us pray. At that very moment, another
preacher of the same cast with the former, rose in the pulpit
to preach another sermon. I proceeded to pray, feeling a tender
concern for the salvation of my fellow creatures, and expecting
shortly to appear before my Judge. The people became very
much affected, and the house was filled with the cries of
distress. Some of the preachers (Who had condemned
the meetings and move) jumped out of a window back of the
pulpit, and left us.
Forgetting my weakness, I pushed through the crowd from one
to another in distress, pointed them the way of salvation,
and administered to them the comforts of the gospel. My good
physician was there, came to me in the crowd, and found me
literally wet with sweat. He hurried me to his house, and
lectured me severely on the impropriety of my conduct. I immediately
put on dry clothes, went to bed, slept comfortably, and rose
next morning relieved from the disease which had baffled medicine,
and threatened my life. That night's sweat was my cure, by
the grace of God. I was soon able to renew my ministerial
labors, and was joyful to see religion progressing. This happy
state of things continued for some time, and seemed to gather
strength with days. My mind became unearthly, and was solely
engaged in the work of the Lord. I had emancipated my slaves
from a sense of right, choosing poverty with a good conscience,
in preference to all the treasures of the world. this revival
cut the bonds of many poor slaves; and this argument speaks
volumes in favor of the work. For of what avail is a religion
of decency and order, without righteousness?
There
were at this time five preachers in the Presbyterian connection,
who were in the same strain of preaching, and whose doctrine
was different from that taught in the Confession of Faith
of that body. Their names were, Richard McNemar, John Thompson,
John Dunlavy, Robert Marshall, and myself; the three former
lived in Ohio, the two latter in Kentucky. David Purviance
was then a candidate for the ministry, and was of the same
faith. The distinguishing doctrine, which we boldly and every
where preached, is contained in our Apology, printed shortly
after that time, which I desire to be reprinted with these
memoirs of my life, affixed to the same volume. From some
of the sentiments of this Apology we afterwards dissented,
especially on the Atonement, as stated in that book.
The distinguishing doctrine preached by us was, that God loved the world--the
whole world, and sent his
Son to save them, on condition that they believed in
him--that the gospel was the means of salvation--but that
this means would never be effectual to this end, until believed
and obeyed by us--that God required us to believe in his son,
and had given us sufficient evidence in his Word to produce
faith in us, if attended to by us--that sinners were capable
of understanding and believing this testimony, and of acting
upon it by coming to the Saviour and obeying him, and from
him obtaining salvation and the Holy Spirit. We urged upon
the sinner to believe now, and receive salvation--that
in vain they looked for the Spirit to be given them, while
they remained in unbelief--they must believe before the Spirit
or salvation would be given them--that God was as willing
to save them now, as he ever was, or ever would be--that
no previous qualification was required, or necessary in order
to believe in Jesus, and come to him--that if they were sinners,
this was their divine warrant to believe in him, and to come
to him for salvation--that Jesus died for all, and that all
things were now ready. When we began first to preach these
things, the people appeared as just awakened from the sleep
of ages--they seemed to see for the first time that they were
responsible beings, and that a refusal to use the means appointed,
was damning sin.
The sticklers for orthodoxy amongst us writhed under these doctrines,
but seeing their mighty effects on the people, they winked
at the supposed errors, and through fear, or other motives,
they
did not at first publicly oppose us. They painfully saw their Confession
of Faith neglected in the daily ministration (This is the protestant version of the Roman Catholic
continuous sacrifice spoken of in Daniel) by the preachers
of the revival, and murmured at the neglect. In truth,
that book had been gathering dust from the commencement of
the excitement, and would have been completely covered from
view, had not its friends interposed to prevent it. At
first, they were pleased to see the Methodists and Baptists
so cordially uniting with us in worship, no doubt, hoping
they would become Presbyterians. But as soon as they saw these
sects drawing away disciples after them, they raised the sound
of alarm--the confession is in danger!--the church is in danger!
O Israel to your tents!
These
sticklers began to preach boldly the doctrines of their confession,
and used their most potent arguments in their defense. The
gauntlet was now thrown, and a fire was kindled that threatened
the ruin to the great excitement; it revived the dying spirit
of partyism, and gave life and strength to trembling unfaithful
and lifeless professors. The sects were roused. The Methodists
and Baptists, who had so long lived in peace and harmony with
the Presbyterians, and with one another, now girded on their
armor, and marched into the deathly field of controversy and
war. These were times of distress. The spirit of partyism
soon expelled the spirit of love and union--peace fled before
discord and strife, and religion was stifled and banished
in the unhallowed struggle for pre-eminence. Who shall be
the greatest, seemed to the spirit of the contest--the salvation
of a ruined world was no longer the burden, and the spirit
of prayer in mourning took its flight from the breasts of
many preachers and people. Yet there were some of all the
sects who deplored this unhappy state of things; but their
entreating voice for peace was drowned by the din of war.
Though
the revival was checked, it was not destroyed; still the spirit
of truth lingered in our assemblies, and evidenced his presence
with us. One thing is certain, that from that revival a fountain
of light has sprung, by which the eyes of thousands are opened
to just and proper views of the gospel, and it promises fair
to enlighten the world, and bring them back to God and his
institutions.
In
this state of confusion, the friends of the Confession were
indignant at us for preaching doctrines so contradictory to
it. They determined to arrest our progress and put us down.
The Presbytery of Springfield, in Ohio, first took McNemar
through their fiery ordeal, for preaching these anti-calvinistic
doctrines. From that Presbytery his case came before the Synod
at Lexington, Kentucky. That body appeared generally very
hostile to our doctrine, and there was much spirited altercation
among them. The other four of us well knew what would be our
fate, by the decision on McNemar's case; for it was plainly
hinted to us, that we would not be forgotten by the Synod.
We waited anxiously for the issue, till we plainly saw it
would be adverse to him, and consequently to us all.
In
a short recess of Synod, we five withdrew to a private garden,
where, after prayer for direction, and a free conversation,
with a perfect unanimity we drew up a protest against the
proceeding of Synod in McNemar's case, and a declaration of
our independence, and of our withdrawal from their jurisdiction,
but not from their communion. This protest we immediately
presented to the Synod, through their Moderator--it was altogether
unexpected by them, and produced very unpleasant feelings;
and a profound silence for a few minutes ensued.
We
retired to a friend's house in town, whither we were quickly
followed by a committee of Synod, sent to reclaim us to their
standards. We had with them a very friendly conversation,
the result of which was, that one of the committee, Matthew
Houston, became convinced that the doctrine we preached was
true, and soon after united with us. Another of the committee,
old father David Rice, of precious memory, on whose influence
the Synod chiefly depended to reclaim us, urged one argument
worthy of record, it was this--that every departure from Calvinism
was an advance of atheism. The grades named by him were, from
Calvinism to Arminianism--from Arminianism to Pelagianism--from
Pelagianism to deism--from deism to atheism. This was his
principal argument, which could have no effect on minds ardent
in the search of truth.
The committee reported to Synod their failure in reclaiming us; and
after a few more vain attempts, they proceeded to the solemn
work of suspending us, because we had departed from the standards
of their church, and taught doctrines subversive of them. Committees were immediately sent to our congregations to read the
Synod's bull of suspension, and to declare them vacant. However
just their decision might be with respect to the other four,
in suspending them for the crime of departing from the Confession
of Faith, yet all plainly saw that it was improper with regard
to me, seeing I had not received that book at my ordination,
nor ever before, more than any other book, i.e. as far as
I saw it agreeable to the word of God. Their bull
was "a blow in the air" as regarded me. I am therefore
an ordained preached by the imposition of the hands of the
Transylvania Presbytery, and as I have not formally been excluded
from the communion of that church, I can yet claim it with
just right. We insisted that after we had orderly protested, and withdrawn, that
the Synod had no better right to suspend us, than the pope
of Rome had to suspend Luther, after he had done the same
thing. We contended, if Luther's suspension was valid, then
the whole protestant succession was out of order, and of course,
that the Synod had no better right to administer in the gospel
than we--that their act of suspension was void.
This
act of Synod produced great commotion and division in the
churches; not only were churches divided, but families; those
who before had lived in harmony and love, were now set in
hostile array against each other. What scenes of confusion
and distress! not produced by the Bible; but by human authoritative
creeds, supported by sticklers for orthodoxy. My heart was
sickened, and effectually turned against such creeds, as nuisances
of religious society, and the very bane of Christian unity.
Immediately
after our separation from Synod, we constituted ourselves
into a Presbytery, which we called the Springfield Presbytery.
We wrote a letter to our congregations, informed them of what
had transpired, /79/ and promised shortly to give them and
the world a full account of our views of the gospel, and the
causes of our separation from Synod. This book we soon after
published, called The Apology of Springfield Presbytery. In
this book we stated our objections at length to the Presbyterian
Confession of Faith, and against all authoritative confessions
and creeds formed by fallible men. We expressed our total
abandonment of all authoritative creeds, but the Bible alone,
as the only of our faith and practice. This book produced
a great effect in the Christian community; it was quickly
republished by the Methodists in Virginia, except our remarks
upon creeds.
The
presses were employed, and teemed forth pamphlets against
us, full of misrepresentation and invective, and the pulpits
every where echoed their contents. These pamphlets and harangues
against us excited inquiry and conviction in the minds of
many, and greatly conduced to spread their views. The arguments
against us were clothed with such bitter words and hard speeches,
that many serious and pious persons, disgusted and offended
with their authors, were driven from them, and cleaved to
us.
Soon
after our separation, I called together my congregations,
and informed them that I could no longer conscientiously preach
to support the Presbyterian church--that my labors should
henceforth be directed to advance the Redeemer's kingdom,
irrespective of party--that I absolved them from all obligations
in a pecuniary point of view, and then in their presence tore
up their salary obligation to me, in order to free their minds
from all fear of being called upon hereafter for aid. Never
had a pastor and churches lived together more harmoniously
than we had for about six years. Never have I found a more
loving, kind, and orderly people in any country, and never
have I felt a more cordial attachment to any others. I told
them that I should continue to preach among them, but not
in the relation that had previously existed between us. This
was truly a day of sorrow, and the impressions of it are indelible.
Thus
to the cause of truth I sacrificed the friendship of two large
congregations, and an abundant salary for the support of myself
and family. I preferred the truth to the friendship and kindness
of my associates in the Presbyterian ministry, who were dear
to me, and tenderly united in the bonds of love. I preferred
honesty and a good conscience to all these things. Having
now no support from the congregations, and having emancipated
my slaves, I turned my attention cheerfully, though awkwardly,
to labor on my little farm. Though fatigued in body, my mind
was happy, and "calm as summer evenings be." I relaxed
not in my ministerial labors, preaching almost every night,
and often in the day time, to the people around. I had no
money to hire laborers, and often on my return home, I found
the weeds were getting ahead of the corn. I had often to labor
at night while others were asleep, to redeem my lost time.
Under the name of Springfield Presbytery we went forward preaching,
and constituting churches; but we had not worn our name more
than one year, before we saw it savored of a party spirit.
With the man-made creeds we threw it overboard, and took the
name Christian--the name given to the disciples by
divine appointment first at Antioch. We published a pamphlet on this
name, written by Elder Rice Haggard, who had lately united
with us. Having divested ourselves of all party creeds, and
party names, and trusting alone in God, and the word of his
grace, we became a by-word and laughing stock to the sects
around; all prophesying our speedy annihilation. yet from
this period I date the commencement of that reformation, which
has progressed to this day. Through much tribulation and opposition
we advanced, and churches and preachers were multiplied.
For
your information I insert the Last Will and Testament of Springfield
Presbytery. /81/
THE LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT OF SPRINGFIELD PRESBYTERY
For
where a testament is, there must of necessity be the death
of the testator; for a testament is of force after men are
dead, otherwise it is of no strength at all, while the testator
liveth. Thou fool, that which thou sowest is not quickened
except it die. Verily, verily I say unto you, except a corn
of wheat fall into the ground, and die, it abideth alone;
but if it die, it bringeth forth much fruit. Whose voice then
shook the earth; but now he hath promised, saying, yet once
more I shake not the earth only, but also heaven. And this
word, yet once more, signifies the removing of those things
that are shaken as of things that are made, that those things
which cannot be shaken may remain.--Scripture
LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT, &c.
The
Presbytery of Springfield, sitting at Caneridge, in the county
of Bourbon, being, through a gracious Providence, in more
than ordinary bodily health, growing in strength and size
daily; and in perfect soundness and composure of mind; but
knowing that it is appointed for all delegated bodies once
to die; and considering that the life of every such body is
very uncertain, do make, and ordain this our last Will and
Testament, in manner and form following, viz:
Imprimis. We will, that this
body die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body
of Christ at large; for there is but one body, and one Spirit,
even as we are called in one hope of our calling.
Item. We will, that our name
of distinction, with its Reverend title, be forgotten,
that there be but one Lord over God's heritage, and his name
one.
Item. We will, that our power of making laws for the government
of the church, and executing them by delegated authority,
forever cease; that the people may have free course to the
Bible, and adopt the law of the Spirit of life in Christ
Jesus.
Item. We will, that candidates
for the Gospel ministry henceforth study the Holy Scriptures
with fervent prayer, and obtain license from God to preach
the simple Gospel, with the Holy Ghost sent down from
heaven, without
any mixture of philosophy, vain deceit, traditions of men,
or the rudiments of the world.
And let none henceforth take this honor to himself, but
he that is called of God, as was Aaron.
Item. We will, that the church
of Christ resume her native right of internal government--try
her candidates for the ministry, as to their soundness in
the faith, acquaintance with experimental religion, gravity
and aptness to teach; and admit no other proof of their authority
but Christ speaking in them. We will, that the church of
Christ look up to the Lord of the harvest to send forth
laborers into his harvest; and that she resume her primitive
right of trying those who say they are apostles, and are
not.
Item. We will, that each
particular church, as a body, actuated by the same spirit,
choose her own preacher, and support him by a free will offering,
without a written call or subscription--admit
members--remove offences; and never henceforth delegate
her right of government to any man or set of man whatever.
Item. We will, that the people
henceforth take the Bible as the only sure guide to heaven;
and as many as are offended with other books, which stand
in competition with it, may cast them into the fire if they
choose; for it is better to enter into life having one book,
than having many to be cast into hell.
Item. We will, that preachers
and people, cultivate a spirit of mutual forbearance; pray
more and dispute less; and while they behold the signs of
the times, look up, and confidently expect the redemption
draweth nigh.
Item. We will, that our weak
brethren, who may have been wishing to make the Presbytery
of /83/ Springfield their kind, and wot not what is now become
of it, betake themselves to the Rock of Ages, and follow Jesus
for the future.
Item. We will, that the Synod
of Kentucky examine every member, who may be suspected
of having departed from the Confession of Faith, and suspend
every such suspected heretic immediately; in order that the
oppressed may go free, and taste the sweets of gospel liberty.
Item. We will, that Ja--------
---------, the author of two letters lately published in Lexington,
be encouraged in his zeal to destroy partyism. We
will, moreover, that our past conduct be examined into by
all who may have correct information; but let foreigners beware
of speaking evil of thinks which they know not.
Item. Finally we will, that
all our sister bodies read their Bibles carefully,
that they may see their fate there determined, and prepare
for death before it is too late.
Springfield
Presbytery,
June
28th, 1804
Robert
Marshall,
John
Dunlavy,
Richard
McNemar,
B.
W. Stone, Witnesses
John
Thompson,
David
Purviance,